Darwin's Metaphor:
Nature's Place in Victorian Culture
by
The nineteenth-century debate on "man's place in nature" ranged broadly and
deeply. It engaged the reading public at every level, leading popular periodicals to
follow closely developments in biology, geology, brain research, psychology, natural
theology, and political economy. New ideas were not fragmented into academic disciplines
but were viewed as part of a common set of themes for a common culture. Great issues hung
on them: the basis for morality and responsibility; the relations between 'races' and
between humans and other species; hopes for the future of society and for an afterlife. In
this collection of six closely interrelated essays, written between 1968 and 1973, Robert
Young emphasizes the scope of the Darwinian debate and challenges the approaches of the
scholars who write about it. He is sharply critical of the separation of the writing of
history from writing about history - historiography - and of the separation of history
from politics and ideology, both then and now. Contending the fellow historians have
reimposed the very disciplinary boundaries that the nineteenth-century debate showed to be
in the service of Victorian ideology, Dr. Young advocates full recognition and open debate
of contending positions. Discussion of the relationships among values, politics and
nature, Young argues, must be retrieved from scholarly obscurantism. Darwinism is the main
scientific theory that places humanity in nature. How we think about it plays a major role
in deciding the place of nature in our culture, just as it did in Victorian culture.
Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 1985. Pp. xx+341
Contents.
Preface: a personal perspective
1. The impact of Darwin on conventional
thought
2. Malthus and the evolutionists: the common
context of biological and social theory
3. The role of psychology in the
nineteenth-century evolutionary debate
4. Darwin's metaphor: Does nature select?
5. Natural theology, Victorian periodicals, and the
fragmentation of a common context
6. The historiographic and ideological contexts
of the nineteenth-century debate on man's place in nature
Notes
Bibliography
Index